Pangolin seizure RM8.4m, but fine only RM250k
Published on: Sunday, March 03, 2019
Text Size:
About a week before, on Feb 7, Malaysia witnessed its most significant win against pangolin trafficking when the police and Sabah Wildlife Department (SWD) shut down a pangolin processing factory and warehouse, seizing a monumental 30 tonnes of pangolin and their parts.
The bust even blew the 2017 record out of the water. That was the year over 17 tonnes of African pangolin scales were intercepted by Customs, and linked to seizures involving Peninsular Malaysia, Sabah and Sarawak.
The 30-tonne seizure in Sabah followed enforcement successes in Vietnam, Hong Kong and Uganda and was massive by any standards. It accounted for 76pc of the 40 tonnes seized globally, and this was just in the first two months of 2019.
The neat rows of close to 2,000 boxes that filled three containers, and the almost 600 frozen pangolins packed into six freezers in the two facilities that were raided, clearly showed the terrifying rate at which pangolins are being wiped out.
Imagine how much more is going unnoticed as criminal masterminds get away with organised crime. Was this syndicate collecting and distributing pangolins from across Borneo – and if so, for how long?
Sadly, this level of extraction is not new. A decade ago, the SWD found a stack of logbooks in a pangolin processing warehouse. The logbooks, which were shared with TRAFFIC, revealed that about 22,200 pangolins were killed, and over 800kg of pangolin scales were supplied to a single syndicate within a 13-month period. Locations for records, including of sources and destinations, were Kota Kinabalu, Keningau, Kota Belud, Kota Marudu, Ranau, Tawau, Tamparuli, Sandakan, Sipitang, Papar and Beaufort.
Organised crime, exemplified by syndicates like this, also typically don’t see their masterminds on the frontline. It is impossible for only one individual to account for the loss of thousands of pangolins.
We urge the authorities to study the financial flows of the illegal business all the way to its top gun and possibly bring forward money-laundering charges against those involved.
This is also important because the worst financial penalty the suspect in the Feb case may get, if convicted under Sabah’s Wildlife Conservation Enactment, is a fine of RM250,000. Meanwhile, the authorities have valued the seized items at RM8.4mil, making the syndicate’s revenue 33 times higher than the law’s heftiest fine.
The string of notable seizures in Malaysia, particularly since 2017, highlights the country’s critical role in the poaching and trafficking of both Asian and African pangolins.
These seizures also reinforce the fact that the authorities have the ability to take down such smuggling operations and help answer the numerous questions that are in everyone’s minds – is Malaysia really a consumer country that uses tonnes of pangolins? Were these for local or international demand? If it’s the latter, who are these Malaysians that are part of an international smuggling ring? How are they scouring, poaching, processing, consolidating, redistributing and trafficking pangolins across national and international borders and continue to sully the country’s reputation?
Most important is the golden opportunity these enforcement successes have created – a chance to dig into and unearth the underbelly of a vast criminal network and ensure it doesn’t regroup and resurface after a period in hiding.
We are heartened that the authorities continue to remain vigilant, making a seizure of 23 pangolins from a Sarawak man trying to cross into Sabah just a week after the mega bust.
So, we are hopeful that nothing is spared in the pursuit of all those who ultimately reap the greatest profits from this criminal enterprise.
Well-organised, well-funded and incredibly nimble wildlife crime syndicates have remained a step or 10 ahead of poorly staffed and under-funded enforcement agencies around the world. TRAFFIC’s research has shown smugglers using an average of 27 new global trade routes annually to smuggle over 120 tonnes of pangolins.
How can individual enforcement agencies keep up, let alone defeat these criminal networks on their shoe-string budgets and the perennial lack of boots on the ground? They can’t, not on their own. The kind of cooperation seen between the agencies in this case is the way forward.
In fact, there are many more agencies and private entities out there that can help wildlife authorities battle the criminals. Among them are those in the logistics and transport sector that move consignments in and out of local and national jurisdictions. It’s high time all parties stepped up and played their part.
The role this country plays in wildlife trafficking has landed it with a prickly label – an unfavourable image it will want to shake off. Detailed and thorough investigations, and strong convictions will help Malaysia do that – help figure out where the real problems lie and bring into clear focus the issues that must be addressed.
Shy and quiet, pangolins have always stood little chance in the wild against the human predator. No threatened species can withstand such industrial-level extraction.
How long can Malaysia’s Sunda Pangolin population survive before it is wiped out? Literally toothless and being able to curl up into a ball being their only defence (pic), they are, unfortunately, set up for failure.
Malaysia’s ability to learn from this incredible loss in Sabah, and act with urgency, might just give them a fighting chance.
ADVERTISEMENT
