Kuala Lumpur: The Attorney General’s Chambers (AGC) has objected to Bersatu’s application for leave to initiate a judicial review against Dewan Rakyat Speaker Datuk Johari Abdul and four members of parliament from Sabah.
Bersatu had filed the legal action for Johari to declare as vacant the seats held by the four MPs.
Senior Federal Counsel Ahmad Hanir Hambaly, representing the AGC told the High Court here that Bersatu’s application should be refused as the decision is not amenable to judicial review by virtue of Article 63 of the Federal Constitution (FC).
“The anti-hopping law as stated in Article 49 of the Federal Constitution is not amenable to a judicial review due to Article 63 of the constitution,” he said in his submission before Judge Datuk Amarjeet Singh.
Article 63 states that the validity of any proceedings in either House of Parliament or any committee thereof shall not be questioned in any court.
The application for the judicial review was filed by Bersatu vice president Datuk Seri Ronald Kiandee and Datuk Captain (Rtd) Muhammad Suhaimi Yahya as public officers of the party on April 17.
Bersatu named Johari and MPs Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali (Papar), Khairul Firdaus Akbar Khan (Batu Sapi), Datuk Jonathan Yasin (Ranau) and Datuk Matbali Musah (Sipitang) as the first to fifth respondents.
Meanwhile, lawyer Tan Sri Azhar Azizan Harun appearing for Kiandee and Muhammad Suhaimi submitted that the judicial review application should be heard as it is not frivolous and vexatious.
“The speaker has exceeded his jurisdiction as he has no power to interpret the constitution of Bersatu or to make a determination of when the membership of the second to fifth respondents in Bersatu ceased.
“The determination of the speaker is irrational and unlawful as it misinterprets the provisions of the constitution of Bersatu and is accordingly an error of law,” said the former Dewan Rakyat Speaker.
Judge Amarjeet said he would deliver his decision on November 16.
In the application, Bersatu is seeking an order to revoke a decision made by Johari, through a letter dated last January 16, which stated that the second to fifth respondents had clarified and confirmed that there was no vacant parliamentary seat based on the interpretation of the constitution of Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) and Bersatu.
Bersatu is also seeking a declaration that the four MPs had ceased to be members of the Dewan Rakyat in accordance with Article 49A of the Federal Constitution, as well as an order for Johari to confirm the four seats as vacant.
